ASAP ACTION ALERT + Quick Update

The Washington region’s Transportation Planning Board (TPB for short) is asking the public for feedback on future highway projects, including the Moore-Hogan toll lanes.

  • Our input is key: in May, the TPB will vote to include – or not include – the I-495/I-270 and Southside toll lanes in its long-range plan, called Visualize 2050.

  • The TPB vote matters because projects like the toll lanes “must be in the TPB plan to receive federal funding and approvals.” MDOT clearly wants a ‘yes’ vote.

  • But we and our elected allies are asking the TPB to reject the toll lanes with their $50 tolls, worsening congestion for the majority, increased inequity, taxpayer jeopardy, and enormous environmental harm.

  • The deadline to submit feedback to the TPB is March 30, just days away. The Action Item below takes only a few minutes. Please act now!

Source: Visualize 2050

ACTION ITEM

Let the Transportation Planning Board hear your voice! Using the instructions below, open the TPB feedback form and say ‘no’ to three toll lane projects on I-495 and I-270. You’ll be focusing on Tab 3 and then Tab 5 of the form.

Refer to these navigation steps as you go:

  • Open the feedback form and click on Tab 3 at the upper right.

  • You’ll see a map with light brown balloons indicating toll lane projects (“HOV/HOT/Express Lanes”).

  • The three brown balloons you’re going to process one at a time are:
    1) Near Rockville, for the toll lanes from I-270 to I-370;
    2) Near the I-270 Y split for the toll lanes from the I-270 West Spur across the American Legion Bridge to the George Washington Parkway; and
    3) Near Alexandria for the Southside toll lanes going along I-495 over the Wilson Bridge into Maryland as far as Oxon Hill. (For more about the Southside toll lanes see “Virginia’s Eye on MD” here.)

  • Click on one of the three brown balloons. In the pop-up box, click NO, you do not support the project. Click on the speech bubble next to the NO box to enter a comment.

  • Then repeat with the other brown balloons.

  • When you are finished, click on Tab 5, Wrap Up.

  • If you wish, answer the optional questions. To add any additional comments, click on the speech bubble at the upper right.

  • Click Finish to submit your form.

  • Thank you! Please share this Action Item with others.

Quick Update: Lawsuit

  • As reported by Maryland Matters last week, “A federal judge dismissed a lawsuit…seeking to block a proposed expansion of the Capital Beltway and Interstate 270.” The judge said the plaintiffs “have not demonstrated that defendants’ actions were arbitrary and capricious.”

  • Per Sierra Club of Maryland Director Josh Tulkin, “This is a disappointing outcome…This project comes with real harms to people and the environment, and MDOT and FHWA ignored important aspects of that harm while reviewing the project.”

  • The Natural Resources Defense Council, one of the plaintiffs in the case, has said the team “is reviewing the opinion and considering their options.”

  • Maryland Matters says, “Even with the ruling, the widening project remains at a standstill….it is not clear how or when the project will proceed.”

  • Our coalition of environmental advocacy organizations, civic and grassroots groups, and elected allies is as determined as ever to oppose the inequitable, destructive Moore-Hogan toll lanes. Thank you, always, for being part of the effort.

What are Moore’s REAL plans for I-270/I-495??

It’s time for our governor to tell the public and our elected representatives exactly where the administration is going with its plan for a big “something” based on Larry Hogan’s massively flawed toll lane project. Moore is now asking the General Assembly to approve another $107 million (p. 300) taxpayer dollars for toll lane planning and engineering (separate from the billions eventually needed for construction). We have questions.

What is the administration’s actual project plan? 

  • MDOT marketing makes it easy to think the project is mainly about public transit. But public transit accounts for only 3% of the project budget.

  • The same marketing makes it easy to shift focus away from toll lanes benefiting only the wealthiest. But MDOT’s application for federal funding (p. 14) makes it clear this is still Hogan’s plan as it was approved in August 2022, with all the inequities and harms intact.

  • The administration is not candid about specifics of project scope, design, and implementation. Does or doesn’t the toll lane plan include lower I-270? What would replace the American Legion Bridge (which is not falling down). ­One span? two? How will construction be phased? Which acres of trees, which community sound walls would come down? And on and on and on.

Where will all the money come from?

  • The project’s Phase 1 budget (p. 10) is over $4 billion. MDOT’s request for $2.4 billion in federal dollars was turned down this year. MDOT Secretary Wiedefeld threw cold water on public-private-partnership funding: “The reality is taxpayers are still going to pay” (see “Wiedefeld Explains” here). And the state has a serious transportation funding deficit.

  • There’s no money for the Moore-Hogan toll lane project now, and no guarantee there will be money next year.

Moore can turn this around by taking action in the public interest.

Right now, our governor faces widespread public, county, and General Assembly dismay over cuts to transportation projects statewide. He also faces growing opposition to the unworkable toll lanes. Instead of diverting $107 million to keep the toll lane plan in a holding pattern for another year, Moore can:

  • Remove the $107 million from his budget and use that bucket of funds towards restoring and expanding critical transit/transportation projects across the state.

  • Announce the end of this toll lane project as part of a realignment of state transportation policy with Moore’s key administration goals: environmental action, equity, and connecting people with jobs.

  • Look to the smart, effective alternatives already on the table for the I-270/I-495 corridor (see here and here and here).

  • Prioritize transportation planning and genuine transit alternatives for I-270 North.

  • Continue seeking federal funding to repair and redeck (resurface) the American Legion Bridge, rather than unnecessarily replacing it.

Action Item

Write to Gov. Moore to urge him to end the Moore-Hogan toll lane plan now, while the General Assembly is considering the new state budget. Ask him to use the $107 million currently designated for toll lane planning/engineering to instead help fund projects that actually meet transportation needs across the state. In your own words, explain why you don’t want the Moore-Hogan plan to move forward. You can find links to an array of ideas and resources in recent DontWiden270.org newsletters.

To take action, click here, select “Transportation” from the dropdown menu, and write your message to Gov. Moore. Thank you.

That’s Settled: Federal Government NOT Paying for Moore-Hogan Toll Lanes

Governor Moore asked the US Department of Transportation for federal grant dollars to build Hogan-era toll lanes. USDOT wisely chose to put its dollars elsewhere this year.

That leaves the Moore administration with three options:

  • Option 1 (the second worst): Wait and reapply for next year’s grants. Here’s what will happen during the wait: MDOT will continue wasting scarce taxpayer dollars (over $76 million in 2024-25 alone) on toll lane planning (p. 300); the lawsuit challenging the project will likely be decided; opposition to the toll lanes will grow.

  • Option 2 (the worst): Switch to the for-profit P3 model Hogan championed. Pressure for this will surely come from Virginia, whose I-495 NEXT toll lanes have no MD construction to connect to. Fault VDOT for demolishing their highway tree canopy, tearing down sound walls, and pouring concrete before MD's plans were set. To see what makes this option the worst, read “Wiedefeld Explains”, below.

  • Option 3 (the clear best): Treat the USDOT grant decision as a fortuitous second chance to cancel Hogan’s plan. Then take a fresh look at the public’s real transportation needs and the smart, equitable alternatives already on the table.

Credit: Maryland Matters, 1/27/24

Action Item: Register for Feb. 6 Zoom Town Hall

 To hear the latest toll lane developments, sign up for the virtual Town Hall sponsored by Citizens Against Beltway Expansion (CABE) and DontWiden270.org. The Town Hall is on Tuesday, February 6, at 7:30 p.m. Register now to join us!

A highlight of the meeting will be a discussion with State Delegate Marc Korman (D16). Maryland Matters recently said about Del. Korman: “The new chair of the House Environment and Transportation Committee has been ‘Mr. Transportation’ throughout his legislative career and will be at the center of the fight to push back on the Moore administration’s proposed spending cuts…” You won’t want to miss this. Zoom Town Hall, Feb. 6 at 7:30. 

Secretary Wiedefeld explains what’s wrong with a P3

MDOT Secretary Wiedefeld had a most informative conversation with State Senator Cheryl Kagan (D17) on the Senator’s podcast, “Kibbitzing with Kagan”. Responding to her questions about the toll lane plan, the Secretary gave a clear and convincing argument against public-private partnership financing for the toll lane project (minutes 22:12 to 23:27).

Here (very slightly edited for clarity and conciseness) is what he said about the P3 venture:

  • “Financially that was probably going to dig us a bigger and bigger hole because we had very limited control over that. There is a time and a place for public private partnerships. I just think the more complicated some of these projects are, it's a little bit more difficult. Because you give up a lot of the ability to control the future.”

  • “And you're doing it at a cost. The reality is the taxpayers are still going to pay for it in some fashion… [The private partners] basically need to deliver the same project. They need to make margin…Now they have dollars to do that. There are ways they can do that. But at the end of the day the customer's going to pay.”

  • “They're not giving the state money. So I think on these very complex projects, you really have to think through that. And that's really what we did. And the contractor did as well…financially, the numbers were not working any longer without even a larger investment by the state.”

 Thank you for this, Senator Kagan and Secretary Wiedefeld.