Private Toll Lanes: A Financial Trap for the Public

Gov. Moore clearly understands that highway tolls are a problem for Marylanders. He just ordered a pause to increases in MD’s current public tolls. He said, “I know that times are tough, and when costs go up, government should be looking for ways to bring them down.”

These would be wise words if Gov. Moore weren’t deep in the process of setting Marylanders up for 50+ years of private tolls aimed at maximizing the revenue of toll-lane giants. On his watch, two public-private toll lane projects (P3s) are advancing toward approval.

Private for-profit toll lanes are a trap

By intention, the wealthy few pay sky-high tolls to use fast lanes while most of the public sits in congested general lanes. Also by intention, MD taxpayers will end up compensating toll lane developers for revenue shortfalls. As former MDOT Secretary Paul Weidefeld said of highway P3s, “The reality is the taxpayers are still going to pay for it…” (22:12 to 23:27).

The financial trap expands over time. Toll lane development diverts resources from other critical transportation needs. And the power to control MD’s transportation policies and budget shifts away from the public and its representatives to the private sector with its longterm contracts and ability to keep creating new bottlenecks that “require” new toll lanes.

Plan 1: I-495/American Legion Bridge/I-270 toll lanes

The first of the financial traps is Gov. Moore’s adoption of Larry Hogan’s plan for toll lanes over the American Legion Bridge to the I-270 West Spur and eventually Lower 1-270. The Moore administration is actively pushing this forward in cooperation with the Trump administration (4:45-17:02). The project’s immense flaws and harms and the public’s strong opposition have been well documented since 2018 [here and here for starters].

Archive image from 2019 of Plan 1 opposition (Credit: Sierra Club)

Plan 2: Southside Toll Lanes from VA into MD

The second financial trap is Virginia’s unprecedented push to build its own private Southside toll lanes inside Prince George’s County, MD. As far as the public can tell, the Moore Administration is giving this high-risk proposal a free pass. MDOT has not told the public how the Southside plan would benefit Maryland. MDOT has not insisted that VA conduct Southside traffic studies requested by the Regional Transportation Planning Board. MDOT has not called for measures to protect MD’s drivers and taxpayers.

If both plans are implemented…

If the Moore administration succeeds in pushing Plan 1 and accepts Plan 2, Maryland will have private, for-profit toll lanes at both ends of the Capital Beltway and, inevitably, two new bottlenecks where the toll lanes end. It’s a trap that will give future MD governors few choices other than to build more toll lanes.

Alternatives to private toll lanes have always been on the table

If the American Legion Bridge needs repair, then repair it. But don’t make that the pretext for creating a massive financial trap. There are multiple ways to reduce congestion that “do not require billions of dollars in new infrastructure investment using risky financing methods.” MDOT used Innovative Congestion Management to significantly reduce congestion on lower I-270. The MD Transportation Institute at the University of MD determined that a 5% reduction in vehicles would reduce congestion 32% or more. Yet the Moore administration has stuck to former Governor Hogan’s pre-pandemic, pre-telework, pre-AI toll lane plan.

TAKE ACTION: Say “NO” to unaffordable private, for-profit toll lanes

Gov. Moore made a promise to leave no one behind. But with these two plans, he’s favoring the wealthy few and turning state transportation projects into unaffordable financial traps for the public. In your own words, based on your own experiences and concerns -- including about rising costs and economic uncertainty -- tell Gov. Moore this is not what the public wants or needs.

To send Gov. Moore a message, click here. Thank you!

Next
Next

Join This 8/25 Online Action: Help Stop Private, For-Profit Toll Lane Expansion